These are Long Island’s 12 Best Italian Restaurants

by Mike Simonson
New York City isn't the only place with great Italian food.

Long Island has long been a bastion of great Italian cuisine.

We've compiled a list of our favorite Italian spots - and included 12 in all because it was so hard to whittle it down to anything smaller.

New York City isn’t the only place with great Italian food. Long Island has long been a bastion of great Italian cuisine. We’ve compiled a list of our favorite Italian spots – and included 12 in all because it was so hard to whittle it down to anything smaller. Leave your favorites in the comments section.


ADVERT


Manetta’s

Long Island City

Get cozy by the fire at this longtime standby in Long Island City and enjoy a brick oven pizza with fresh mozzarella, pesto pasta or some of the best pappardelle in the area. Reasonably priced and with a homey atmosphere, Manetta’s has an ample menu that is bound to appeal to most. Website.

Vincent’s Clam Bar

Carle Place

From the baked clams oreganato to the lobster kiss, if it’s Italian style seafood you’re after,Vincent’s is the place to go. Seafood isn’t the only thing on the menu, Italian classics like eggplant rollentini and pork saltimbocca are excellent choices. You can even buy their freshly made sauces to take home with you. Website.

Luce Ristorante

East Norwich

A little bit of Tuscan sophistication on Long Island, Luce Ristorante’s open and elegant atmosphere is a perfect match for its refined menu. Don’t find something you like? Luce’s chef will make something just for you. Add an excellent wine list and top notch service and you can see why Billy Joel loves Luce Ristorante. Website.

Cirella’s

Melville

Come for the Italian food and sushi, stay for the live jazz. Ample portions and a casual atmosphere make Cirella’s great for family dining during the day while evening entertainment offers something a bit more grown up. Be sure not to miss the antipasti. Website.

Carlino’s Restaurant

Mineola

Eat in, take out or have your event catered. Whatever you choose, Carlino’s will provide an authentic and outstanding Southern Italian experience. The dining rooms are intimate, the staff friendly and the menu ample. Check out Carlino’s and bring your appetite. Website.

Franina Restaurant

Syosset

Voted Number One Italian restaurant by Zagat.com, Franina’s offers an intriguing mix of traditional Italian dishes such as grilled Mediterranean octopus and some more exotic choices for the adventurous foodie like wild boar sausage. There are a number of organic options and the organic pasta is hand cut by Franini’s own chefs. All in all, dining at Franini’s is an exquisite experience. Website.

Da Noi Italian Restaurant

Islip

With an emphasis on local ingredients, Da Noi is Islip’s hidden little gem. Da Noi’s pasta is made fresh and to order. That’s right, fresh handmade pasta on the spot. The veal has been described as heavenly and the sea bass is not to be missed. If you can manage to keep a little space for dessert, consider the tazzia di profiterole- puff pastries filled with Chantilly cream, ensconced in vanilla and chocolate cream. Yum… Website.

Galleria Ristorante

Westbury

A crisp, clean, modern appearance enhances the fine Italian offerings at Galleria. Rated four stars by the New York Times, Galleria employs an attentive staff that makes every visit feel like going home again. A few nights a week, diners can enjoy live soft piano music. For some of the freshest fish on Long Island and an espresso that can’t be beat, try Galleria’s. Website.

Verace

Islip

Another authentic Italian find in Islip, Verace’s offers gluten free, fixed price lunch and late night dining menus along with its standard lunch and dinner menus. You’ll be hard pressed to decide what to order with all of the options but that won’t be a problem since you can’t make a bad choice. Any restaurant that serves something called a nutella bomb is a place that should be on your “must try” list.
The ossobuco is a winner by any standards. Website.

Manducati’s

Hunters Point

A straightforward family owned place, Manducati’s doesn’t put on any airs. What it does put on is a feast of the old school Italian variety. The menu is deceptively simple but all of the basics are covered and executed to perfection. Featured in Absolute Magazine, The Daily Meal, Eater.com and given a four star review by Newsday, don’t let Manducati’s no frills nature fool you. The cuisine is world class. Website

Stresa

Manhasset

Old world charm and European elegance combine to give the impression that one is dining in one of New York City’s long established Italian venues. Tending towards Northern Italian fare, Stresa is reminiscent of the golden age of fine dining. The owners are known to go out of their way to make customers feel pampered. You’ll feel like a guest in someone’s home when you dine at Stresa. Of particular note is the Rigatoni Stresa and the Classic Creme Brulee. Website.

La Scala Restaurant and Pizzeria

Commack

La Scala is know for serving some of the best thin crust pizza on Long Island, but you do yourself a disservice if you stop there. An unassuming little shop at the front, a peaceful dining room at the back, La Scala’s offers many excellent non-pizza entrees such as shrimp fra diavolo and mussels marinara. There are lighter options for lunch and La Scala’s does a booming takeout business selling slices, full pizza and heroes. Do yourself a favor and don’t overlook the stunning dessert tray. Website.



FEATURED EVENTS

New York Wine Events

September 23, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Kotti Berliner – Food & Wine Pairing

Join us for a Virtual Food & Wine Pairing with Brooklyn’s Kotti Berliner. Explore delicious döner kebabs paired with wine. Meet Kotti founder, Erkan Emre.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

September 16, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Broadbent Selections – Portugal

Join us for a Virtual Tasting with one of America’s leading importers of high-quality Portuguese wines.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

September 2, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Cusumano Winery – Sicily, Italy

Join us for a Virtual Tasting with the maker of the #1 selling Sicilian wine in the U.S.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

August 26, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Kunde Family Winery

Join us for a Virtual Tasting. The Kunde family has farmed an 1,850-acre estate in Sonoma Valley for 100 years.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

August 19, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

LangeTwins Family Winery and Vineyards

Join us for a Virtual Tasting. Great wine starts in the vineyard.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

August 12, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Dutcher Crossing Winery

Join us for a Virtual Tasting. Distinctive and hand-crafted wines produced from award-winning vineyards.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

June 12, 2020

At Your Home

RGNY At-Home Blending Session

Be your own winemaker for a day — guided by a professional on Zoom video!

PURCHASE KIT & ZOOM TICKET
New York Wine Events

May 29, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Virtual Wine & Pizza Tasting with Jamesport Vineyards

What’s better than great wine and artisanal pizza?

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 28, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Foxen Winery & Vineyard Virtual Tasting

Experience the magic of Santa Barbara wine.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 28, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Foxen Winery & Vineyard Virtual Tasting

Experience the magic of Santa Barbara wine.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 21, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Chateau Montelena Winery Virtual Tasting

This tasting will be epic.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 19, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Ridge Vineyards Virtual Tasting – Monte Bello winery

The New York Times described Ridge Monte Bello as “America’s greatest Cabernet Sauvignon.”

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 18, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Tenuta di Lilliano Virtual Tasting

Very special tasting. Don’t miss it!

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 15, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Pedroncelli Winery Virtual Tasting

Four Generations of Family Pride at Pedroncelli Winery, since 1927

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 14, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Provence Rosé Group Virtual Tasting

The best rosé in the world comes from Provence.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 13, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

St. Francis Winery Virtual Tasting

Voted “#1 in America” in 2013 and 2015 by Open Table customers.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 12, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Ridge Vineyards Virtual Tasting – Lytton Springs

The New York Times described Ridge’s Cabernet Sauvignon as America’s greatest.

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 11, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Oak Farm Vineyards Virtual Tasting

Visit the famous wine-growing region of Lodi County, California – virtually!

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

May 8, 2020

Live Online Zoom Broadcast

Goldschmidt Vineyards Virtual Tasting

Visit Sonoma County – virtually!

RSVP FOR FREE
New York Wine Events

April 18, 2020

Marlboro, NY

Wines & Bites!

Hudson Valley’s yummiest wine and food tasting event

GET TICKETS
New York Wine Events

March 7, 2020

New York’s Premier Winter Wine Event

NYC Winter Wine and Food Festival

Enjoy a winter getaway without even leaving the city.

GET TICKETS
New York Wine Events

January 19, 2020

Riverhead, NY

RG|NY Blending Session

Join RG|NY winemaker Lilia Perez, for a unique tasting and blending session.

PURCHASE TICKETS
New York Wine Events

December 14, 2019

Ulster & Orange Counties, NY

Wreath Fineries at the Wineries

Don’t miss the ultimate holiday wine tasting event in the Hudson Valley. Sales end Thursday, Dec 12 at 11:59pm!

PURCHASE TICKETS
New York Wine Events

November 14, 2019

New York, NY

Around The World In 10 Wines

Experience a global tasting in 2 hours with award-winning artisan cheese and charcuterie

PURCHASE TICKETS
New York Wine Events

November 9, 2019

Brooklyn

Brooklyn Crush: Fall Edition

Experience the event Thrillist said was one of the things “You Absolutely Have to Do in NYC”

PURCHASE TICKETS

RELATED WINE BLOGS

Wednesday, November 18th, 2020

Wines for Thanksgiving 2020
Well, somehow we have made it to the end of 2020 and it’s time for the holiday season. Things are going to look different this time around – smaller gatherings, less traveling, not getting to watch your dad almost light the fried turkey on fire. The great thing about new situations is the ability to - Read More
Read more...

Thursday, October 22nd, 2020

Get Ready for the Holidays
Somehow, 2020 is still going, and we’re almost at the holiday season. But what is time!  Anyway, you and your loved ones deserve some delicious wine for the holidays this year – well, you always do but it really feels necessary for 2020. Whether you’re having a Friendsgiving or actually making a trek to see - Read More
Read more...

Wednesday, October 7th, 2020

Event Spotlight: 2020 Virtual Autumn Wine & Food Festival
Every year, we look forward to our flagship event, the Autumn Wine & Food Festival. Bringing all of our guests together to celebrate small shops producing the most delicious food and wines – it is truly a joy!  So, we won’t lie and say there is disappointment in not being able to host this in - Read More
Read more...
LOAD MORE